It became clear early during his first training camp that George Pickens had the talent. He dazzled fans at Saint Vincent College in 2022 with seemingly daily displays of one-handed and/or “contested” catches, combined with good size and breakaway speed.
It also didn’t take long for it to become clear that all of the ancillary … baggage … that comes with Pickens was going to be a ubiquitous storyline throughout his tenure with the Pittsburgh Steelers.
That tenure ended Wednesday with a trade to the Dallas Cowboys. Pickens lasted three seasons with the Steelers. He led the team in receptions (174), receiving yards (2,814) and receiving touchdowns (12) in that span.
He also led them in times fined by the league and (unofficially) in social-media brouhahas.
A look at some lows and highs of Pickens with the Steelers—
The good: One-handed catch in Cleveland
In just his third career regular-season game and first in prime time, Pickens pulled in a highlight-reel catch early in a loss at the Browns on Sept. 22, 2022.
Are you serious, George Pickens? What a one-handed grab!#PITvsCLE on Prime Video
Also available on NFL https://t.co/uF4okqrMwwpic.twitter.com/4mDGzOOoZu— NFL (@NFL) September 23, 2022
The bad: Scuffle during Hail Mary in Cleveland
As a Russell Wilson desperation throw into the end zone was in the air, Pickens was pushing and shoving with the Browns’ Greg Newsome during the final play of a Nov. 21, 2024, loss to the Browns.
George Pickens fighting Greg Newsome during the Hail Mary LMFAO pic.twitter.com/1QT1sN1w5o
— Clay Fink (@clay_fink) November 22, 2024
The good: 2 long TDs vs. the Bengals
With their 2023 season all but on the line and the Steelers having made the desperate switch to Mason Rudolph at QB, Pickens had touchdown catches of 86 and 66 yards in a 34-11 win on Dec. 23.
Mason Rudolph to George Pickens Passing TD (1/4)
pic.twitter.com/wBxFLCCSj1— NFL TD Videos (@NFLTDVids) December 23, 2023
The bad: 2 unsportsmanlike conduct penalties vs. the Bengals
Pickens is twice flagged and penalized 15 yards apiece for after-whistle taunting and unsportsmanlike calls during a Dec. 1, 2024, win at the Cincinnati Bengals.
.@steelers@bengals Pickens with a taunting call and it should get called....everytime. No one is bigger than the TEAM. Play with class. This stuff in a big game can be the difference between W & L. #HereWeGo#BaldysBreakdownspic.twitter.com/jkC2i8x6rM
— Brian Baldinger (@BaldyNFL) December 2, 2024
The good: Winning TD for Christmas Eve comeback win
Pickens catches a 14-yard touchdown pass from Kenny Pickett with 46 seconds left in an emotional, frigid-cold 2022 victory against the Las Vegas Raiders to cap a week in which franchise icon Franco Harris died.
December 24, 2022 at Acrisure Stadium. The Raiders were winning 10-6 in the 4th QTR. Kenny Pickett threw a 14 yard TD pass to George Pickens with 46 seconds remaining on the clock. The Steelers won this game 13-10. pic.twitter.com/VTgzqPErGl
— Billy Hartford (@CamHeywardFan) September 24, 2023
The bad: Ejected for Thanksgiving-week head-first hit
Pickens is disqualified for the final seconds of a Nov. 20, 2022, home loss to the Bengals when he lunges head-first at Cincinnati’s Tyler Boyd after Boyd accepted the clinching onsides kick. Boyd would later take verbal shots at Pickens and his effect on the Steelers’ locker room.
The good: October ’24 primetime TD, big play
In an Oct. 20 win on “Sunday Night Football” against the New York Jets, Pickens wows with a 44-yard catch down the sideline during the second quarter. Later in the quarter, he had an 11-yard touchdown reception from Wilson.
It would be the final of four career games with the Steelers in which he had more than 100 receiving yards and a touchdown.
Obviously this is a hell of a throw by Russ and catch by Pickens.#Jets 15 #Steelers 13 pic.twitter.com/CMov6j6sCY
— Obviously (Not) Tomlin (@Tomlin_Sense) October 21, 2024
The bad: October ’24 primetime fined for eyeblack, facemask throw
Two weeks before that, also during a home game on “SNF,” Pickens was making headlines for other reasons. He had a profane message on his eye black, and after the seconds ticked off of a Cowboys’ 20-17 win, Pickens grabbed Dallas’ Jourdan Lewis by the facemask and flung him to the ground.
George Pickens grabbed Jourdan Lewis' facemask after the Steelers loss to the Cowboys pic.twitter.com/uD3cZ2KJi1
Featured Local Businesses
— Sportify (@Sportifffy) October 7, 2024
The good: Big blocks against big people
Pickens was never afraid to use his 6-foot-3, 200-pound frame against opposing defenders. His blocking at times endeared himself to fans, teammates and coaches.
The bad: Non-blocks, illegal blocks at inopportune times
Other times, though, Pickens failed at such duties. Once during an October 2023 win at the Los Angeles Rams, he was penalized and fined for an illegal crackback block.
Two months later, his lack of effort on an opportunity to block might have cost the Steelers a Jaylen Warren touchdown.
George Pickens says he didn’t want to get an injury when talking about why he didn’t block for longer on this play.
“I was just trying to prevent the Tank Dell situation, the same thing that happened to him. I ain’t want an injury.”
(Via: @EdwinSphere) pic.twitter.com/zAvkK8DGWi
— JPAFootball (@jasrifootball) December 19, 2023
The good: Clutch plays late in big game
Twice during the fourth quarter of a one-possession game during Week 17 of the 2023 season, Pickens made crucial catches for big plays to help seal a win at the Seattle Seahawks. The first was for 34 yards from Rudolph on a third-and-6 with 11 minutes, 35 seconds left. The next came just after the 2-minute warning when Rudolph hit Pickens for 24 yards deep into Seattle territory. The win set up a scenario for the Steelers to clinch a playoff berth the following week in Baltimore.
GEORGE PICKENS WOW pic.twitter.com/2aoxTHwucl
— NFL Retweet (@NFLRT) December 31, 2023
The bad: Shows up late for big game
With the division title still well within reach when the Steelers faced the defending Super Bowl champion Kansas City Chiefs on this past Christmas Day, Pickens made a late arrival to Acrisure Stadium, reportedly after 11:30 a.m. for a 1 p.m. kickoff — some 35 minutes after the demands of team policy.
Up this morning at #BreakfastWithBenz--Mike Tomlin's answers about George Pickens raise more questions https://t.co/oHc3lIiMxG@TribSports@TribLIVE
(also includes our final @mybellaroof podcast of the season w/ @C_AdamskiTrib)— Tim Benz (@TimBenzPGH) January 15, 2025
The good: Goes viral on social media
Pickens regularly trended on social media at times during his time with the Steelers, particularly during training camp settings when fans at Chuck Noll Field would post unauthorized videos of spectacular catches.
INSSSSSSAAAANNNNNNNE!!!!
The JPJ and Pickens competition heating UPPPP, Pickens does what Pickens does though and makes the craziest catch I’ve ever seen in person wow man! pic.twitter.com/XKTfOUYScK
— Baku ???? (@Mazursky8895) August 1, 2023
The bad: Goes viral on social media
A day after netting minus-1 yard during a Nov. 11, 2023, win against the Tennessee Titans, Pickens took to his Instagram account. He scrubbed all references to the Steelers and wrote “free me” under a meme. Pickens had been spotted during the game avoiding his teammates’ celebration of a Diontae Johnson touchdown, generally sulking on the sideline and quickly leaving the field as the game ended in victory.
????????????????????????????????: #Steelers WR George Pickens shares a post to his Instagram story after last night’s -1 yard performance.
He says “free me” on the bottom right of the photo. Pickens could be frustrated over the last two weeks.
(H/T: @Blitz_Burgh) pic.twitter.com/bK2uICypUw
— JPAFootball (@jasrifootball) November 3, 2023