Year
Region
Category
All-Around Restaurant
-
WinnerCarriage Inn Restaurant and Catering1601 Lovedale Rd, Elizabeth, PA
-
WinnerCarriage Inn Restaurant and Catering1601 Lovedale Rd, Elizabeth, PAMade fresh, with the best ingredients, our chefs are always making sure they are creating dishes you want to tell your friends and family about. We offer weekly specials and a wide selection of entrees.
Bakery
-
WinnerBethel Bakery5200 Brightwood Rd, Bethel Park, PASince Bethel Bakery opened for business in 1955 in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery's signature pastries, cookies, and one-of-a-kind cakes. With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him, and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. After his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna. Together, the couple built the neighborhood bakery into one of the busiest and most beloved purveyors of high-quality baked goods in Western Pennsylvania. And they did it while raising seven children, all of whom worked in the family business. Today, a second generation of the Walsh family manages the bakery. John and his wife, Chris, took over day-to-day operations in 1991 and expanded the already extensive inventory of baked goods, but Morris and Anna's legacy of exceptional quality and customer service lives on. People travel for miles for a taste of Bethel Bakery's signature buttercream icing and couples across the region wouldn't dream of celebrating their nuptials with anything but a hand-crafted, custom-designed Bethel Bakery cake decorated by one of the shop's talented designers.
-
FinalistPastries A-La-Carte81 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA
-
FinalistParty Cake Shop706 Brookline Blvd, Pittsburgh, PAParty Cake Shop today continues the long tradition of creating delicious cakes, breads, cookies, donuts and pastries that you've come to expect. We specialize in cakes like our famous Burnt Almond torte, decorated cakes for all occasions, wedding cakes, fresh pastries, and holiday items. We have been a Brookline institution for over 60 years and hope to remain for a long time to come.
Breakfast
-
WinnerOur Little Secret Cafe and Catering332 Curry Hollow Rd, Pittsburgh, PAOur Little Secret is an authentic restaurant and catering company for those who are passionate about food!
-
FinalistBob's Diner1815 Mckees Rocks Rd, Mc Kees Rocks, PAIn the late seventies, Bob Marshall and his father visited Louie’s Diner on Commercial Boulevard in Ft. Lauderdale Florida, and it quickly became their favorite place to eat. With counter, booth and table service, Louie’s became an inspiration for Bob, and he was determined to have his own diner someday. His father’s influence stuck with him as well – just look for the Dad’s Favorite breakfast on the menu!
-
FinalistBob's Diner211 Mansfield Blvd, Carnegie, PAIn the late seventies, Bob Marshall and his father visited Louie’s Diner on Commercial Boulevard in Ft. Lauderdale Florida, and it quickly became their favorite place to eat. With counter, booth and table service, Louie’s became an inspiration for Bob, and he was determined to have his own diner someday. His father’s influence stuck with him as well – just look for the Dad’s Favorite breakfast on the menu!
Burger
-
WinnerBubba's Gourmet Burghers and Beer Southpointe114 Southpointe Blvd, Canonsburg, PAAward-Winning Gourmet Burghers and Beer!
-
FinalistElrama Tavern1520 Pa837, Elrama, PAThe Tavern is a neighborhood bar and restaurant located in the small town of Elrama. We truely have something for everyone!! Prime Rib dinners to Bluegrass Bands to offsite catering.
-
FinalistMulligan's Sports Bar & Grill1013 Lebanon Rd, West Mifflin, PA
Candy
-
WinnerSarris Candies511 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA
-
WinnerSarris Candies511 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PASarris Candies, known for not only its superior rich taste, but adherence to high quality standards and exceptional customer service for over 50 years, has evolved into the epitome of the American dream.
-
FinalistMy Favorite Sweet Shoppe1597 Washington Pike, Bridgeville, PABy providing quality hand-dipped chocolates and partnering with the best vendors, we guarantee that all our guests can find something to satisfy their sweet tooth! Our variety of homemade choices includes Gourmet Caramel Apples, fresh fudge, hand-dipped chocolates, and specialty, custom designed treats!
Caterer
-
WinnerPasta Too5260 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PAPasta Too is a family-owned Italian Restaurant located in Bethel Park in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, PA. Three generations of restaurant business experience and homemade family recipes made with traditional flavors and ingredients are what differentiate Pasta Too from other Italian food options in the area. The establishment prides itself on its familial values, and creating an authentic Italian dining experience for every customer.
-
WinnerPasta Too5260 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PA
-
FinalistCooked Goose Catering Company7851 Steubenville Pike, Oakdale, PA
Chicken Wings
Chinese Restaurant
-
WinnerSilk Road Gourmet Chinese5301 Grove Rd Ste 1, Pittsburgh, PA
-
WinnerSilk Road Gourmet Chinese5301 Grove Rd Ste 1, Pittsburgh, PAAt Silk Road, our Lunch and Dinner menus are available for dine-in, delivery and take-out, and include a wide array of Asian cuisine, including your favorite traditional Chinese entrees, appetizers, soups, noodle and rice dishes and desserts. Prepared fresh daily by Master Chef Wu, we offer a variety of beef, chicken, pork, seafood and vegetarian options that are sure to satisfy any appetite. We are also pleased to offer a full-service bar, complete with beer, wine, sake and liquor to compliment your meal. All wines featured with our meals have been specifically selected for Silk Road by Bruce May, nationally-known wine critic and writer for Pittsburgh Magazine.
-
FinalistYa Fei1980 Park Manor Blvd, Pittsburgh, PATraditional and Contemporary Asian Cuisine.
Diner
Fish Sandwich
-
WinnerDorido's Restaurant6408 Brownsville Rd, Pittsburgh, PADorido's Restaurant provides delicious appetizers, homemade soups, desserts, and kids' menu items to South Park, PA.
-
WinnerDorido's Restaurant6408 Brownsville Rd, Pittsburgh, PA
-
FinalistDowney's House6081 Steubenville Pike, Mc Kees Rocks, PAWelcome to Downey’s House! If you’re looking for a great place to stop for lunch, dinner or drinks in Robinson Township, you’ve found it! We have an extensive menu, a comfortable atmosphere and it’s always fun. You’ll feel like part of the family when you’re here!
Food Truck
Ice Cream
-
WinnerSarris Candies511 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA
-
WinnerSarris Candies511 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PASarris Candies, known for not only its superior rich taste, but adherence to high quality standards and exceptional customer service for over 50 years, has evolved into the epitome of the American dream.
-
FinalistHandel's Homemade Ice Cream2240 Lebanon Church Rd, West Mifflin, PAOur mouth-watering ice cream loves a good pairing. You will, too, when it’s combined with a traditional Cake Cone, Sugar Cone, Waffle Cone (try it hand-dipped in chocolate!) or Waffle Bowl. With choices like that, there’s no wrong way to serve up a scoop.
Italian Food
-
WinnerPasta Too5260 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PA
-
WinnerPasta Too5260 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PAPasta Too is a family-owned Italian Restaurant located in Bethel Park in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, PA. Three generations of restaurant business experience and homemade family recipes made with traditional flavors and ingredients are what differentiate Pasta Too from other Italian food options in the area. The establishment prides itself on its familial values, and creating an authentic Italian dining experience for every customer.
-
FinalistAlla Famiglia804 E Warrington Ave, Pittsburgh, PAEnjoy traditional, fresh Italian food, warm hospitality, and exemplary service. Feast on prime aged steaks, milk-fed veal, homemade pastas, or wild exotics from the sea. Pair it with a craft libation or select a bottle of wine from our award-winning wine list. Make sure you save room for our homemade desserts and sweets from our pastry chef, Mara Beck!
Local Coffee Shop
-
WinnerThe Coffee Tree Roasters5840 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PAThe Coffee Tree Roasters first opened its doors in Squirrel Hill, Pennsylvania in 1993 as a simple coffee shop with a small batch in-store roaster.
-
FinalistReginald's Coffee2600 South Park Rd, Bethel Park, PA
-
FinalistReginald's Coffee2600 South Park Rd, Bethel Park, PAReginald's Coffee is a specialty coffee roaster with a cafe in a historic landmark in the heart of Bethel Park (30 minutes south of Pittsburgh). We're a local husband-and-wife team, and our story started with a passion for 3 things—coffee, dogs, and old buildings—and one simple question: can the suburbs be cool? So, we got to work. We found space in an old schoolhouse, designed a cafe centered around the history of the building, named it after our dog, started roasting some of the best beans you can get, hired some of the best people you can find, and then right here in the 'burbs began serving coffee to some of the coolest people anyone could ever meet: you.
Mexican Food
-
WinnerEl Campesino4097 William Penn Hwy, Monroeville, PAAuthentic Mexican Restaurants with 7 locations Serving Pittsburgh PA for over 28 years
-
WinnerEl Campesino4097 William Penn Hwy, Monroeville, PA
-
FinalistPlaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant · Robinson Township1000 Sutherland Dr, Pittsburgh, PAAt Plaza Azteca, we offer a genuine welcoming, warm and friendly atmosphere with thoughtful service to make you feel truly at home. Whether you are looking for a relaxing escape or culinary experience, we are dedicated to meeting your individual needs.
Outdoor Dining
Pizza
-
WinnerMineo's Pizza House2128 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PAMineo's Pizza House is a Pittsburgh family owned and operated pizza restaurant since 1958 with three generations.
-
WinnerMineo's Pizza House713 Washington Rd A, Mt Lebanon, PAMineo's Pizza House is a Pittsburgh family owned and operated pizza restaurant since 1958 with three generations.
-
FinalistYoli's | Cucina and Crafthouse1101 Pa885, Jefferson Hills, PAYolanda went by the nickname Yoli. She was the cornerstone and matriarch of the family. She was known for her compassionate spirit and her delicious cooking. Every Sunday she would have the entire family over for pasta and meatballs. This is why we use the name, Sunday Sauce, for our house pasta sauce. Yoli made sure that no one left her table hungry. Second helpings were always a must. The memories from around her table full of laughter with her, aunts, uncles and many cousins are some of Ben's best memories of his childhood. Ben quickly learned growing up that feeding family with great food and showing love were synonymous in the DiGregory household. This is why the tag line for Yoli's Cucina and Craft house is, We feed you like family. We want to make sure that when you come in to dine with family, friends, or even a quick bite by yourself that with every bite you take you feel like a part of our Yoli's Cucina family. We strive to make sure that the food we prepare for you, the service we provide and the experience you have are exceptional. After all, Grandma Yoli's legacy is on the line and that is a lot to live up to.
